How to choose the right thermoplastic for your industrial application
Choosing the right plastic material is essential for an industrial component to function properly. But which thermoplastic is best, and when? PAI, PEEK, and PPS are three high-performance thermoplastics with different strengths and applications. Here we go through what distinguishes them and the factors you need to consider to choose the right material for your application.
Why is the right choice of thermoplastic material important?
Thermoplastics often need to handle multiple stresses simultaneously, such as high temperatures, chemicals, mechanical strain and repeated friction. If the plastic material cannot withstand these stresses, it can lead to machines breaking down, becoming worn out or experiencing impaired functionality. Therefore, choosing the right thermoplastic for the right application is absolutely crucial.
Temperature, for example, affects the material's strength and dimensional stability, while chemicals can alter the material's properties. Prolonged mechanical stress can, in turn, lead to deformation. Therefore, choosing materials based on a single characteristic is not enough. Choosing the right material involves balancing function, lifespan, processing, and overall cost.
What characteristics should be compared?
When choosing thermoplastic material, you need to base your choice on the component’s actual operating conditions. Here are some of the most important characteristics to compare:
Temperature resistance
Look both at the normal operating temperature and short-term temperature peaks. It is important to consider whether the plastic can withstand temperatures in the long term or only for a limited time. PAI, PEEK, and PPS all tolerate elevated temperatures, but they have different mechanical properties at high temperatures.
Mechanical load and creep
What forces must the component withstand? Does it need to withstand pressure, tensile forces, bending or repeated loads? A key factor is creep, which means that the material slowly deforms under constant load. PAI is particularly interesting when high compressive strength and low creep are important. PEEK offers good mechanical performance and fatigue resistance, while PPS is less suitable for heavy loads.
Friction and wear
In applications such as bearings, bushings and sliding surfaces, friction affects how much heat is generated, how much energy is consumed and how long the component lasts. Therefore, it may be beneficial to choose materials that are specifically designed to reduce friction and wear. Examples of such materials are PAImed graphite and PTFE, PEEKHPV and the Techtron HPV PPS quality.
Chemical resistance and moisture
If the component comes into contact with chemicals, water, or steam, you need to investigate how the material is affected by the specific environment. Concentration, temperature, and exposure time play a major role. PEEK, for example, has good hydrolysis resistance, while both PEEK and PPS have good resistance to many chemicals. PAI may also be suitable, but must be evaluated based on the current quality and exposure conditions.
Dimensional stability
In many applications, the material needs to maintain its dimensions during operation. Temperature changes, humidity, and mechanical stress can otherwise affect fit and function. PAI has very good dimensional stability and low creep behavior. PPS has low moisture absorption and low thermal expansion, while PEEK offers good dimensional stability in many demanding situations and applications.
Processing and cost
The choice of material also affects how the component can be manufactured and the tolerances that can be achieved. PAI, for example, is more demanding to process than many other engineering plastics. The cost of the material also needs to be weighed against its lifespan and maintenance. PEEK generally has a high material cost, while PPS can often be a cheaper option in the long run.
PAI – the right choice when performance and dimensional stability are important
PAI, or polyamideimide, is a high-performance thermoplastic that, as mentioned earlier, is often suitable when high demands are placed on mechanical strength, temperature resistance, and dimensional stability. At Carlsson & Möller we offer PAI from the Torlon® brand, in several different qualities.
What characteristics distinguish PAI?
PAI combines high mechanical strength with low creep behavior and low thermal expansion. This makes PAI interesting for components that need to maintain their shape under prolonged loads and at elevated temperatures.
When is PAI suitable?
PAI can be the right choice for, for example:
- Storage and shelf holders.
- Bearings and sliding components.
- Valve details.
- Distances and precision components.
There are also PAI qualities with additives of graphite and PTFE that provide improved friction and wear properties.
What limitations does PAI have?
PAI has relatively low impact strength and can be sensitive to heavy impacts and sudden changes in load. Processing is also more demanding than for many other thermoplastics. For certain qualities and applications, post-curing may be necessary to achieve the desired material properties. It is therefore important to choose the right quality and take into account both the design and the processing.
PEEK – for high temperatures and demanding chemical environments
PEEK, or polyetherketone, combines good mechanical strength with high temperature resistance and very good chemical resistance. PEEK is often used when conventional construction resins cannot meet the application requirements.
What characteristics distinguish PEEK?
PEEK has good mechanical strength, fatigue resistance and dimensional stability. In addition, the material has very good hydrolysis resistance, which makes it interesting when in contact with hot water and steam. PEEK resists many chemicals, but not all. For example, exposure to concentrated sulfuric acid needs to be evaluated with particular care.
When is PEEK suitable?
PEEK can be used in, for example:
- Valve details and valve blocks.
- Bearings and bushings.
- Pump components.
- Precision details.
- Process equipment.
PEEK is a common choice when a thermoplastic needs to meet multiple requirements simultaneously, such as high temperature, mechanical stress, and chemical exposure.
Different PEEK qualities have different properties
For example, unfilled PEEK 1000 has good toughness and impact strength. Reinforced grades with glass or carbon fiber can provide higher stiffness, while tribologically modified grades such as PEEK HPV and PEEK TX are designed for applications with specific requirements regarding friction and wear. This means that the material selection is not just about choosing PEEK, but also about finding the right quality.
What limitations does PEEK have?
Material cost is often the biggest limitation of PEEK. PEEK is indeed a relatively expensive engineering plastic and may be an unnecessarily advanced choice if another quality meets the requirements. Cracking, friction, and dimensional changes also need to be evaluated based on the current quality and load.
PPS – chemical resistant and dimensionally stable
PPS, or polyphenylenesulfide, is an advanced thermoplastic that stands out for its good chemical resistance, low moisture absorption and dimensional stability. PPS can be an interesting choice when applications come into contact with chemicals, water or steam. It can also be a cost-effective option when the application does not require the specific performance of PEEK or PAI. At Carlsson & Möller we offer PPS from the brand Techtron®, Among others, in the Techtron 1000 and Techtron HPV qualities.
What characteristics distinguish PPS?
PPS has good resistance to many acids, bases, solvents and other chemical substances. The material also has very low moisture absorption, which contributes to good dimensional stability. The temperature stability is also good, provided that the current quality and load are adapted to the operating conditions.
When is PPS suitable?
PPS can be used for example:
- Pump details and pump wheels.
- Bearings and bushings.
- Valve components.
- Roller and wheels.
- Components in the process industry.
Techtron 1000 and Techtron HPV – what is the difference?
Techtron 1000 is an unfilled PPS grade suitable for components where chemical resistance, temperature resistance and dimensional stability are important. Techtron HPV is a tribologically modified grade with a uniformly distributed lubricant. It provides improved friction and wear properties and makes the material interesting for applications such as bearings and bushings.
What limitations does PPS have?
PPS has relatively low impact strength and can be susceptible to severe impacts and shock loads. Therefore, it needs to be considered when designing components with dynamic loads. The machining process also needs to be adapted to the material properties and quality.
PAI, PEEK or PPS – which material should you choose?
PAI, PEEK and PPS all have properties that make them interesting for demanding industrial applications, but their strengths differ. To make the choice easier, we have put together this table:
| Property | PAI (Torlon) | PEEK (Ketron) | PPS (Techtron) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Temperature resistance | Very high | Very high | High |
| Mechanical performance | High compressive strength and low creepage | High strength and fatigue resistance | Good rigidity and strength |
| Chemical resistance | Varies with quality and environment | Very good against many chemicals | Very good against many chemicals |
| Hydrolysis resistance | Needs to be evaluated for the application | Very nice | Very nice |
| Friction and wear | Very good in modified qualities | Very good in modified qualities | Very good in Techtron HPV |
| Dimensional stability | Very good, low latency | Good varies with quality and load | Very good, low moisture absorption |
| Processing | Relatively demanding | Requires custom processing | Requires custom processing |
| Relative material cost | High | High | Generally lower |
In short, PPS is suitable when chemical resistance, dimensional stability and temperature resistance are important, and can be a more cost-effective alternative to PEEK. PEEK is suitable when several high requirements need to be met simultaneously, for example in terms of temperature resistance, chemical resistance and mechanical performance. PAI is particularly interesting when high compressive strength, low creepage and dimensional stability are crucial, for example in bearings and precision components.
How do you choose the right thermoplastic for your application?
A good material choice starts with the component's actual application area. Feel free to follow these steps to make the choice easier:
1. Map out the operating conditions
Start by finding out:
- Normal operating temperature and any temperature peaks.
- What chemicals the material comes into contact with.
- Presence of water, steam or moisture.
- Mechanical load and movement patterns.
- Any friction and sliding contact.
- Desired lifespan.
2. Identify the most important requirements
Then distinguish between characteristics that are absolute requirements and those that are desirable. In a chemical process, chemical resistance, for example, can be crucial, whereas extreme pressure resistance may not be necessary. This helps you avoid choosing an unnecessarily advanced and expensive material.
3. Compare different material qualities
Do not compare PAI, PEEK and PPS as material families alone. Even different grades within the same family can have significant differences. For example, an unfilled PEEK grade has different properties than a glass fiber reinforced or tribologically modified variant.
4. Road performance versus total cost
Keep in mind that a more expensive plastic may be more economical in the long run if it provides longer lifespan and fewer component replacements. At the same time, a cheaper material may be fully sufficient if it meets all requirements.
5. Verify the choice of materials
Always check the correct material data sheet and quality. If necessary, calculations and practical tests may be required to ensure that the component can withstand the load.
This is particularly important when multiple stresses are present simultaneously or when a component failure could have major consequences.
Do you need help choosing the right thermoplastic?
Choosing the right thermoplastic can be complicated when several technical requirements need to be met simultaneously. It can also be difficult to know which material quality is best when the properties differ between different versions. At Carlsson & Möller we have extensive experience working with thermoplastics. With a wide range of plastics, extensive experience and high material expertise, we help you find the solution that provides the best functionality, lifespan and economy.
Would you like to discuss which thermoplastic you should choose? Contact us and we will help you find the right solution!